Skip to content
SHOP THANKSGIVING PREORDERS
About
Sweets
Minis
Wedding
Holiday
Shipping Boxes
FAQs
Contact
The Cookie Exchange
Log in
Instagram
About
Sweets
Minis
Wedding
Holiday
Shipping Boxes
FAQs
Contact
The Cookie Exchange
Search
Log in
Cart
Item added to your cart
View cart
Check out
Continue shopping
KELSEY ELIZABETH
brownies & bars
BROWNIES: $3.75
A soft, chewy, chocolatey base with buttercream and toppings.
Birthday Cake Oreo
Snickers
Triple Chocolate
Reese's Brownie
White Chocolate Raspberry
Cookie Dough
Flirty Brownie
S'mores
Buckeye Brownie
Salted Carmel Toffee
Black & White
French Silk Pie
Peanut Butter Oreo
Puppy Chow
Neapolitan
Blondies: $3.75
Similar to a Brownie, but with a vanilla base instead of chocolate.
Cake Batter
Blueberry Pancake
Toffee Caramel
White Chocolate Raspberry
Apple Crisp
Lemon
Strawberry Lemon
Fluffernutter
Snickerdoodle
BARS $3.75
Hard to explain. Just trust us—they are delicious.
Banana Bread Bar
Sugar Cookie Bar
Almond Raspberry Cookie Bar
Buckeye Cookie Bar
Twix Cookie Bar
Apple Cake Bar
SEASONAL FLAVORS
Our flavors only available around certain holidays.
Eggnog Blondie
Peppermint Brownie
Red Velvet Blondie
Crème Brûlée
Gingerbread Cookie Bar
Pumpkin Bar
need care instructions or have questions?
VISIT FAQs
Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
Opens in a new window.